Pew: State pension systems improve, but $1.2 trillion in unfunded liabilities remain
National News
Audio By Carbonatix
2:45 PM on Thursday, November 19
(The Center Square) – State pension systems are in better financial shape than they were earlier this decade, but more than $1 trillion in unfunded retirement obligations remain, and six states are falling further behind in paying down their debt, according to new research from The Pew Charitable Trusts.
Pew's latest report found that the combined net pension liability across all 50 states declined from $1.3 trillion in 2023 to $1.2 trillion in 2024. The overall funded ratio, which measures how much of states’ promised retirement benefits are covered by existing assets, increased from 74% to nearly 77%.
Strong investment returns were the primary driver of the improvement, helping reduce pension liabilities by approximately $190 billion, according to the report.
David Draine, lead researcher with The Pew Charitable Trusts, told The Center Square that one of the most encouraging findings is that most states are now making sufficient contributions to prevent their pension debt from growing.
“From 2020 to 2024, the majority of states are meeting this benchmark,” Draine said.
Pew’s net amortization benchmark measures whether states are contributing enough money to reduce their unfunded pension liabilities, assuming actuarial expectations are met.
Forty states achieved positive net amortization over the five-year period, meaning their contributions were sufficient to make progress paying down pension debt. Four states maintained stable amortization, while six (Illinois, Mississippi, New Jersey, New Mexico, North Dakota, and Texas) experienced negative amortization, meaning they fell further behind.
Draine said states cannot rely indefinitely on strong investment returns to improve their pension finances.
“Obviously, you can't count on that happening forever,” he said, noting that financial markets will eventually experience corrections, downturns, and recessions.
He said the long-term solution is ensuring states contribute enough money to their pension systems, rather than depending on favorable market conditions to close funding gaps.
Many public retirement benefits have strong constitutional protections, meaning states cannot simply walk away from their obligations, according to Draine.
“We've seen in states that have deferred these costs for a long time, they end up starting to make these contributions, and it just ends up being a substantial fiscal burden,” he said. “Ultimately the bill gets paid, it's just when does it get paid, and how burdensome does it become?”
Draine pointed to West Virginia and Indiana as examples of states that have made significant improvements through sustained contributions and deliberate efforts to address pension debt.
West Virginia went from having the nation's worst-funded pension system in 2000 to getting back on track through decades of consistent contributions and dedicating additional revenue, including tobacco settlement funds, to paying down pension debt, according to Draine.
Draine said future pension costs will depend on uncertain factors, including investment performance, demographic changes, and workforce trends. He said stress testing (or risk analysis) is important, which 25 states now use to assess the sustainability of policies and anticipate how economic downturns could affect pension contributions.